Kissena Forum Archive

Weight Loss Discussion

530 comments · 4730 views
thank you alex, haskell, et al.  that is why i always ensure my ice cream is well below 70F before i eat it, and why i only ever eat it by the entire pint, to ensure there is enough of a cold, solid mass in my stomach to bring down my temperature into the 'slough off the pounds like they were flesh off a zombie' zone
Wait, you *eat* the ice cream...?

It's
cream right?  I thought it was supposed to be rubbed all over to help cool and soothe with the minty tingles...?
on cream: I've been experimenting with cream... high-quality heavy whipping cream mixed with a dollop of Johnny Robb vanilla egg white protein powder and 1 teaspoon of raw honey. It's, uh, rich. Filling.

Full fat Fage yogurt with the same protein/honey components are my regular stand-in for ice cream.

On chamois cream -I love Assos, and although I think the danger of parabens are probably overstated, I gave Chamois Butt'r a shot and it feels right. 

So good to have high-quality stuff on both ends!
I've got some hillclimb races coming-up, so although I'm moderately happy in keeping in my maintenance mode, under the 170lbs mark --that weight will work me over on a hill-fated competition. So, I'm back at it trying to drop those several KGs that I dropped last year... I just read this post by Lyle McDonald on calories. I think I've posted links to his Bodyrecomposition.com site previously. This one is really good and essentialized.

Speaking of diet books/philosophies in general, Lyle says:
"Whether it’s insulin, dietary fat, the protein:carbohydrate or insulin:glucagon ratio, partitioning or whatever other bullshit, they will make it sound like caloric intake is not the key aspect in whether or not someone gains weight.

In almost all cases, the idea that food intake must be restricted in any fashion is dismissed; if it is mentioned it is generally as a short aside late in the book that nobody pays any attention to.

This is purely a psychological ploy; it sucks to have to consciously restrict food intake and this causes mental stress. Simply knowing that you can’t eat what you want when you want it blows; I hate it as much as the next person. Many people will feel hungrier simply because they know that they can’t eat what they want when they want it.

Yet the fundamental fact is that the body will NOT have any need to tap into stored body fat unless the individual is burning more calories than they are taking in. Of course this means that either energy expenditure has to go up, caloric intake has to go down, or both have to occur."


http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/all-diets-work-the-importance-of-calories.html


p.s. I was so inspired by Lyle's words that I was able to summon massive will power to undermine a major conniption at the grocery store tonight. Salivating like an Olde English Mastiff after chasing poachers off the master's property, I stood motionless in front of the Whole Foods pre-packaged cakes and pies display for several minutes. Somehow I got through that moment with only fish, veggies, fruit and yogurt in my basket.

Got home, cooked up the Halibut hastily marinated in a tarragon/orange/coconut oil concoction, seared it, roasted it keeping it topped-off with marinade and a little butter. Steamed some kale. Sliced an avocado. Supped.

I joke not that the bites of tender fish and creamy avocado together tasted like a mighty delicious, savory donut. I am talking pronounced donut flavor. 



Megalol
Halibut-avacado-maple-bacon-donut?
i don't always eat donuts, but when i do, they are fish flavored

this reminds me of the amazing descriptions of food items by andy zalstman of The Bugle.  most of that podcast is devoted to terrible jokes not worth hearing or repeating.  but the satirical food menus are lovely
Hi all, I'm new here but wanted to share my wisdom. 4 years ago the wife and I imparted on the trip toward being vegan, me being more dragged than anything else. She's a type 1 diabetic (this is insulin dependant, not the one associated with being old/over weight) so she's almost a walking lab when it comes to how our body reacts to things. Overall I've come to the conclusion that a veg diet supplemented with fish 1-2 times per week and eggs the same amount is the best; other protein from grains and beans/legumes. Obvious rules apply like trying to eat organic and eating whole grains, avoiding processed foods. I also don't say I'll never eat something, don't get me wrong I'm not going to an expensive restaurant and eating just veg and the idea of never having pizza or a hamburger again is not good; but the times end up being few and far between.  Starting out its easy to just be a vegetarian during the week, you'll get the majority of the benefits. 

On weight loss, since you'd be cutting out the majority of the thing that have high calories (dairy and meat) while staying away with processed foods. weight will come off if you have excess to spare. Also, consider fasting periods and eating heavier around working out, only 200kcal before, making lunch your largest meal and reducing cal consumption for dinner. The notion of eating many meals a day to lose weight is pretty ridiculous.  Your body won't start to slow its metabolic rate without food for 72+hours and eating more often simply results in eating too much and your body will never have to tap into fat stores as it always has food on board and elevated glucose levels. Finding a 12 hour gap per day in food consumption will help lose body fat; either eat dinner and no breakfast or dinner by 6PM. If you workout in the morning skipping breakfast is obviously not a good idea and vice-versa. Also, switching to a low wheat diet with little meat will result in a 5lb loss of weight simply from the slow moving foods that stay in your system.

Finally, always the question, how do you get enough protein, don't we need protein? Yes, well of course however the average person needs about 10% of their daily calories from high quality protein sources (complete such as soy, eggs, milk; note most meat is a 90% complete protein). An endurance athlete apparently (I didn't do any of the studies I've read) needs ~15% and someone targeting significant muscle growth may need 20%.  Toxic levels are around 25% which is about the average American diet.  I'm ~150lb, I need 80-100g of protein depending on how much I workout that day. Wheat is about 13% protein, so is brown rice and are made a complete protein when paired with beans/legumes. 

So there you go.  The best source for nutrition related advice I have found is on the hammer nutrition site http://www.hammernutrition.com/knowledge/endurance-library/

Happy hunting
Interesting stuff @Scott - thanks for sharing.  And welcome aboard!
Toxic levels? I thought excess protein was passed in the urine.
I love some good science of sport reading as much as the next guy, but this stuff cites no sources and is often penned by one guy.  Perhaps some of the professional scientists could opine...

William Misner, Ph.D.
From 1996 until his retirement in 2006, Dr. Bill worked full-time as Director of Research & Development at Hammer Nutrition. Among his many accomplishments, both academically and athletically, he is an AAMA Board Certified Alternative Medicine Practitioner and the author of "What Should I Eat? A Food-Endowed Prescription For Well Being

I'm not saying he isn't smart but I am saying that this stuff is NOT peer reviewed and the intro to his CV is... unusual.

http://www.pilgrimsmarket.com/pdf/BillMisnerCurriculumVitae.pdf
Jules, don't disagree with your assessment. The guys a bit odd, holistic medicine is not something most people would consider as credible, however his observations seem reasonable, I should have said a good place for nutrition advice, not the best. 
Nutrition tends to be a difficult subject as most major studies concentrate on one specific aspect (calcium, cholesterol, vitamins, etc) which says little about the more systemic issues. As well there always seems to be some deep seated cultural aspects of food and there seems to be extensive articles advocating every possible diet. The China Study is probably the largest single observation of diet in culture and links to disease. It's worth a look in any case. 
And No I am not a Dr. and you are right, largely excess protein is passed in the urine, as far as I know. I use the toxic term loosely as that is the point where calcium absorption is apparently hindered and your blood ph increases (increased ketonic state) which could cause longer-term health issues. Hell the Inuit survive on a 90% protein diet (not to say they are healthy) so what do I know.  
I agree, nutrition is extremely complex and the body is very good at using different sources of fuel to achieve its goals. I think also that it is interesting to look at different ones that focus on certain specifics and that we shouldn't draw hard conclusions. What I find most astonishing though, when looking at professionals' diets is how meals are calculated and intake of calories is measured based on expanditure and basal metabolic rate. I just go by: me hungry, me eat something healthy that tastes good and definitely don't look at my meals in percentage of protein because there are also lots of proteins in vegetable and in sources we least expect them to be present in. I do love meat and I eat red meat not too frequently knowing that high consumption of red meat is tied with increased rates of colorectal cancer. Anyway, I plan on putting on muscle this late fall/winter using this strategy: hit the gym, stay off the bike for a little bit and recover with whey protein and BCAAs.
@Scott - I agree with a whole mess of what you've said. Lunch emphasis, insulin consideration, week-based systems, opportunistic fasting, only indulging in indulgent foods. Small quibble with eating breakfast before working out, depending on the workout. Again, small quibble.

I'll bet your system works quite well for weight loss/management. But as my buddy (and our teammate!) Jules often says, pretty much any restrictive diet tends to lead to weight loss. The "no-white-or-brown-food" diet will lead to weight loss, and probably can be construed to be quite healthy.

My own view on the matter is that the kind of diet you laid out is a pretty darn good one. You're satisfying your caloric needs, you're shitting right, and you won't catch the scurvy. But crucially, you're doing all these things without manipulating your blood chemistry in such a way that you experience swings in your "sensations" that trigger harmful eating impulses. (Which I'm sure your lovely wife/control group can confirm!)

As a guy who has lost a fuck-ton of weight and still struggles to burn it all the way down to the nub, it's my experience that it's the sugar, flour, and other processed ingredients that make food work like drugs. My own experience jibes with some of the stuff I've read (Taubes, Pollen, Cordain, et al): that meat and dairy are uniquely high-quality nutrition sources that incur maximal satiety while inducing little subsequent hunger reaction. Not to mention the theoretically beneficial microfauna that typically come from dairy products such as yogurt and kefir. So I'm not sure that these are the most beneficial things to restrict, in pure nutritional terms.

I look forward to Norm getting in on this discussion. And I look forward to riding with Scott in person!
While you can't really argue with limiting crappy food and reducing excess fat and sugar intake, I'm incredible reticent to in any way put a high protein intake into the 'bad' category.

Also, meat is not 90% protein.  Chicken and beef, the most common meat consumptions I would assume, are 30-40% protein by mass.

 
While you can't really argue with limiting crappy food and reducing excess fat and sugar intake, I'm incredible reticent to in any way put a high protein intake into the 'bad' category.

Also, meat is not 90% protein.  Chicken and beef, the most common meat consumptions I would assume, are 30-40% protein by mass.

 
Duh. Everybody knows that if you want 100% protein by mass you have to go with SPAM. All the pros are doing it...
I read that as SRAM at first.  For a few brief seconds my bullshit front shifting was suddenly explained to me...
Meat is 90% a complete protein, or all the necessary amino acids needed by our body. Soy, Dairy and eggs are complete proteins. A cup of chicken, by calories is 75% protein and the remainder fat. 

Spam however does not have nutritional information as the composition of circus animals they use changes depending on the batch. So I can't really say on that one; for me its a toss up whether scrapple or spam is better... 

Jeff, agree with the points. I like eating more fruit, veg and legumes etc for calories that meat I suppose; also high quality meats are pretty expensive (non industrial farmed stuff). But I hear you- the people that you list are all paleo advocates and both being vegan or paleo can be severely abused; vegan eating processed and junk food and paleo eating lots of low quality meat. At the end of the day humans is that we can eat a ton of different food and thrive, so different things can work. I am glad you put Pollin in there as well, good reads, and his advice "Eat Food. Not too Much. Mostly Plants". Forks over Knives is also pretty good. I too used to be a fat kid and have always struggles with it; though you wouldn't know now. 
FUCK. I just spent like 15 minutes ripping the shit out of Adam and the goddamn forum decided that since I was only typing a brilliant contribution and not mindlessly clicking around on links that it would log me out due to "inactivity."

Suffice it to say, Adam, that you've been owned.
Auto-Signout disabled. Whitey ain't gonna get off that easy... Show us your snark!

I don't know...I think auto-signout may be a blessing in disguise. More than once, when one of you jokers has pissed me off to no end, I've been saved from writing a response. Which I ALWAYS feel thankful, the next day, never got posted.
I really go for anything that has pink frosting on it. Discuss.
Jeff W,

I am not overly sure how you were going to chide me for my comment, the part about reducing intake of crappy foods or that protein is not bad for you?

If it were about the protein content of chicken/beef being 30-40% by mass, please, expaciate.  I'm keen to hear it.

Some of the above posts seem to be mashing together concepts of protein bioavailability, essential vs. non essential amino acids and calorie intake from protein as a fraction of total.  I found a nice (peer reviewed and well referenced) review on this which is very explanatory in this regard.  For those of you who are unfamiliar with the concept of a review, it is written by an "expert" (take that with a pinch of salt) on any given subject.  Reviews almost exclusively do not contain any original research but are a synopsis of current understanding in that particular field.  They are best used to direct you to actual research which use the scientific process to address a specific hypothesis.  Their further benefit is to compile many studies to draw an overriding conclusion.  A word of warning though; reviews should and often do cite very broad sets of research.  However, what research is included in the discussion and what conclusions are drawn are purely the subjective choice of the authors.  Of course, this is supposedly tempered somewhat by the peer review process, but you get what I mean.  In any case, I thought the attached review on protein was very good.  Easy to understand and focusing on some good questions.

Also, Jeff, will be about in Brooklyn later tonight (not my choice, always seem to end up in Williamsburg???) if you are around for beer.  In fact, invitation open to all.  Owens!!!!!!!
Attached...

Today on my morning ride through CP, I stopped and got a doughnut. Then went home. Am I doing it wrong?

Today on my morning ride through CP, I stopped and got a doughnut. Then went home. Am I doing it wrong?
Yes.  

1. eat the donut while you ride.  

2. ride with JP.

3. give him a donut.

4. he'll ride fast.

5. keep up.

6. you'll lose weight.
7. you'll curl up in bed and die in your sleep from all the lactic acid build up that will have caused you to have a cardiac arrhythmia. 

OR

7. you eat the doughnut, he bonks and you win.
I heard alcohol is the best and most calorie dense food around, booze!
Strolling about some food carts in PDX with Wojciech today, I got a visual and a whiff of a burger phenomenon. If only I had a power meter hooked-up to my will, woulda' been off the Coggan charts.